How to replace butter when baking
How to replace butter when baking
Dairy is a delicious and nutrient-dense food, however not everyone can tolerate digesting it. Scientists estimate that 75% of the world’s population is lactose intolerant. Many other people have a sensitivity or allergy to the protein in milk and find their health is better when dairy is left out of their daily diet.
Replacing dairy milk with a nut milk and foregoing cheese are straightforward solutions to going dairy-free. However, converting a baking recipe with butter to a non-dairy alternative can be challenging. I’ve listed a few tips below to help you convert your favorite recipes with success.
Tip 1: Determine the role of butter in the recipe. Butter is comprised of 80% fat and 20% water. When used in baking, the fat provides a softer texture and rich mouth feel while the water provides steam that can help create rise and volume. Butter also has a distinct flavor and the ability to brown. In recipes like quick breads or muffins, butter can often be substituted with bananas, applesauce or pumpkin purees to provide moisture. In recipes where a light, flaky or crisp texture is desired; the fat in the recipe must be substituted in order to produce a similar finished product.
Tip 2: Choose a liquid or a solid fat for substitution. Liquid fats like olive oil and avocado oil can make lovely substitutes in some baked products, especially recipes that call for melted butter. Liquid fats cannot be creamed with sugar to aerate a batter, so they are best to use in products that are moist and dense, like quick breads. Solid fats, however, can be creamed with sugar or rubbed into flour to trap air and provide lift for light, fluffy cakes and flaky crusts. Coconut oil is a plant-based fat that is solid at room temperature, so it behaves similar to butter when baking. One caveat is that butter melts at 90°F while coconut oil melts at 76°F. Coconut oil can easily melt in a warm kitchen thereby losing its ability to aerate your baked products. Chilling the oil in the refrigerator and taking care to not overwork the batter/dough can mitigate this difference.
Tip 3: Adjust the quantity of fat. Unlike butter, coconut oil and liquid fats are 100% fat with no water content. Baked goods can feel heavy and greasy if oil is substituted 1-to-1 for butter. When substituting coconut oil for butter reduce the quantity used by 20-25%.
Tip 4: Add flavor. Olive oil, avocado oil and coconut oil each have their own subtle flavor profiles. Adding vanilla, citrus zest, cinnamon, herbs or an extra pinch of salt can enhance the flavor of the product and make up for the loss of butter flavor.
Converting recipes is a science and often requires trial and error. Don’t be afraid to experiment. I’ve had my fair share of less than perfect baked goods, but they usually always taste great. Through experimentation you will find the perfect replacement to get the light and fluffy or crispy texture you are after.
Additional information about reducing dairy in the diet:
Milk and Health: Research from the New England Journal of Medicine